Court tosses Floton Africa’s 3bn/- defamation suit

Zanzibar: The High Court of Zanzibar has struck out a 3bn/- defamation suit filed by Floton Africa Ltd against Cost-Consultant Limited and the CEO of Shivo SMC Private Ltd, Richard Ashby, ruling that the company failed to demonstrate that the manager who signed and verified its court documents was authorised to act on its behalf.
In a ruling delivered on March 5, 2026, at the High Court in Tunguu, Judge Haji S. Khamis held that the plaint was incompetent because Floton Africa had not produced a board resolution or other documentary evidence establishing the authority of Godfrey Nyigu, identified in the court documents as the company’s manager.
The case, Civil Case No. 70 of 2024, involved a claim by Floton Africa for 3bn/- in damages over an allegedly defamatory report which the company said had damaged its reputation.
The claim comprised 2bn/- in special damages and 1bn/- in general damages. Floton Africa alleged that the defamatory act had been jointly committed by the two defendants.
However, Ashby raised a preliminary objection challenging the company’s legal standing to institute the proceedings, arguing that Nyigu, who signed and verified the plaint as the company’s manager, had not demonstrated the authority required under the Civil Procedure Decree.
ALSO READ: Shivo Towers breaks ground amid island-wide infrastructure surge
His lawyer, Said Ramadhan, submitted that Order XXXIII Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Decree, Cap. 8, permits pleadings on behalf of a corporation to be signed and verified by its secretary, director or agent, provided the person is able to testify to the facts of the case.
He argued that a manager was not automatically authorised to perform that function and that the company had failed to establish Nyigu’s authority.
Floton Africa, through its lawyer Hassan Kijogoo, opposed the objection, arguing that a manager could fall within the category of an agent recognised under the law and could sign and verify pleadings on behalf of a company.
The company further argued that the provisions governing recognised agents did not apply because the proceedings had been instituted in the company’s name rather than by an external representative.
In determining the objection, Judge Khamis agreed that a manager could qualify as an agent of a company under Order XXXIII Rule 1, provided the individual was familiar with the facts of the case and had the necessary authority.
The judge, however, distinguished between holding a managerial position and having formal authority to institute legal proceedings on behalf of a company.
The ruling noted that the plaint merely described Nyigu as a manager, without attaching a board resolution or other documentary evidence showing that the company had authorised him to sign and verify the court documents.
“The burden lay upon the Plaintiff to demonstrate that the person who signed the Plaint was duly authorized in law,” the judge stated.
The court consequently found that, in the absence of proof of authorisation, the plaint was incompetent.
It rejected the request to dismiss the suit, instead ruling that striking it out was the appropriate remedy where a plaint had been signed and verified by a person whose authority had not been established.
The suit was therefore struck out with costs.
The ruling did not examine the substance of the defamation allegations or determine whether the report complained of was defamatory. It also made no finding on the defendants’ liability for the Sh3 billion claimed by Floton Africa.
The decision centred on the procedural and legal requirements governing the authority of individuals signing and verifying court pleadings on behalf of corporate entities.
The ruling was dated March 5, 2026, following proceedings held on February 3 and March 5, 2026.



